Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

I wanted Kai to win, but Phil looked better at the finals. It's ok, I accept it

At the prejudging, phil was picked unanimously over Kai. That is wrong. There is no way in a fair judging that Phil should have won UNANIMOUSLY.

Then there's the whole wolf/manlet gremlin thing, but that's covered in another thread

This judging is one reason why the sport isn't taken seriously. It needs to be fixed

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

Most people had Kai winning in the pre-judging. Phil faded quickly while Kai got better.
In the finals it was closer.

I had Kai winning the show because he was more consistent on both days.

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

I'm waiting to see the scorecards. If Phil took both the prejudging and finals then it's bull****.

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

I don't think it would get accepted even if the judging was spot on. And even though there are some blatent bad calls (like Branch), the judges do have their work cut out for them because they will never, ever be able to please every single person and opinion. If anything, they should make at least half the judging open to the eyes of the public so that we can see who's getting points and in what catagories.

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

the cards are out

phil won pre-judging unanimously

that's what the whole thread is about

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

What is messed up is, M&D is already saying next year is a three way race between Cutler, Heath, and Kai. Of course they threw in the qualifier, barring injury. Really? They already know none of the other top five or top eight will be in the hunt next year?

I don't really care. I'm just hoping Ox hits top five next year.

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

Kai 28 Phil 14

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

I think both were in about equal condition, so it comes down to size, width, structure, musclebellies etc

To me Kai shoud be mr O, when they both bring their a game, Phil is too narrow to get the nod.

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

IMO Kai doesn't have the symmetry or proportions to that of Phil if u ask me. But I'm not a judge.

 

Don't care who you though should win, but this is not right

Hope this helps: